2007
Country Music Association Awards
BMI awards
CMT Music Awards
Nashville Songwriters Association International Award
- Horizon award
BMI awards
- "Tim McGraw" as winning song
CMT Music Awards
- "Tim McGraw" as breakthrough video of the year
Nashville Songwriters Association International Award
- Songwriter/Artist of the Year
2008
Academy of Country Music Awards
American Music Awards
BMI Awards
CMT Music Awards
- Top New Female Vocalist
American Music Awards
- Favorite Country Female Artist
BMI Awards
- "Our Song" as winning song
- "Teardrops on My Guitar" as country song of the year
CMT Music Awards
- "Our Song" as Female Video of the Year
- "Our Song" as Video of the Year
2009
Academy of Country Music Awards
American Music Awards
Country Music Association Awards
Billboard Year End Chart
BMI Awards
CMT Music Awards
Teen Choice Awards
Nashville Music Awards
- "Fearless" as Album of the Year
- Crystal milestone award
American Music Awards
- Artist of the year
- Favorite pop/rock female artist
- Favorite country female artist
- Favorite adult contemporary artist
- "Fearless" album as favorite country album
Country Music Association Awards
- Entertainer of the year
- Female vocalist of the year
- International artist achievement award
- "Fearless" album as album of the year
- "Love Story" as music video of the year
Billboard Year End Chart
- "Fearless" album as the Billboard 200 Album of the Year
- "Fearless" album as top country album of the year
- "Love Story" as hot radio songs of the year
- Artist of the year
- Top country album artist of the year
- Hot adult contemporary artist of the year
- The Billboard 200 artists of the year
BMI Awards
- "Teardrops on My Guitar" as BMI pop award winning song
- "Teardrops on My Guitar" as BMI's president award
- "Picture to Burn" as winning song
- "Should've said no" as winning song
- "Love Story" as country song of the year
CMT Music Awards
- "Love Story" as video of the year
- "Love Story" as female video of the year
Teen Choice Awards
- Choice female artist
- "Fearless" album as choice female album
Nashville Music Awards
- Artist of the year
- Songwriter-artist of the year
- "Fearless" album as country album of the year
2010
Grammy Awards
American Music Awards
Songwriters Hall of Fame
Billboard Year End Chart
BMI Awards
People's Choice Awards
Teen Choice Awards
Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards
- "Fearless" album as album of the year
- "Fearless" album as best country album
- "White horse" as best female country vocal performance
- "White horse" as best country song
- "You Belong With Me" as record of the year
- "You Belong With Me" as song of the year
- "You Belong With Me" as best female pop vocal performance
- "Breathe" as best pop collaboration with vocals
American Music Awards
- Favorite Country Female Artist
Songwriters Hall of Fame
- Hal David Starlight Award
Billboard Year End Chart
- The Billboard 200 artist of the year
BMI Awards
- "You Belong With Me" as country song of the year
- Country songwriter of the year
People's Choice Awards
- Favorite Female Artist
Teen Choice Awards
- "Valentine's Day" as Choice breakout female
- Choice Female Country artist
- "Fifteen" as choice country song
- "Fearless" album as choice country album
Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards
- Favorite Female Singer
- "You Belong With Me" as favorite song
2011
Academy of Country Music Awards
American Music Awards
Country Music Association Awards
Billboard Music Awards
Billboard Year End Chart
Billboard Year End Awards
CMT Music Awards
People's Choice Awards
Teen Choice Awards
- Jim Reeves International Award
- Entertainer of the year
American Music Awards
- Artist of the year
- Favorite country female artist
- "Speak Now" as favorite country album
Country Music Association Awards
- Entertainer of the year
Billboard Music Awards
- Top Billboard 200 artist
- Top Country artist
Billboard Year End Chart
- Top country artist of the year
- "Speak Now" album as top country album of the year
- Top country album artist of the year
Billboard Year End Awards
- "Fearless" as winning song
- "Back to December" as winning song
- "Mine" as winning song
CMT Music Awards
- "Mine" as video of the year
People's Choice Awards
- Favorite Country Artist
Teen Choice Awards
- Red carpet hot icon
- Choice female artist
- Choice female country artist
- Ultimate choice
- "Mean" as choice country song
- "Mine" as choice love song
- "Back to December" as choice break-up song 112, 162